Best Daycares in New Middletown

Browse all 2 licensed daycares in New Middletown, Ohio. Compare program type, SUTQ status, and key details to find childcare that fits your family.

County hubs: Mahoning County

2
Gold SUTQ
100% of programs
About childcare in New Middletown
  • New Middletown has 2 licensed child care providers, including 1 School-based Preschool and 1 Child Care Center.
  • 2 providers (100%) hold a Step Up to Quality rating — 2 Gold.
  • 2 providers (100%) accept Publicly Funded Child Care (PFCC) assistance for income-eligible families.
  • Providers in New Middletown have been licensed for an average of 13 years, with the longest-running program licensed since 2011.

Updating results...

Only locations with address coordinates appear on the map.

Loading map…

No daycares in current map view

Try zooming out or adjusting your search or filters.

Common Questions About New Middletown Child Care

Helpful answers for families searching for daycares in New Middletown, Ohio.

Does a "Not Rated" SUTQ status mean a daycare in New Middletown is low quality?

No. “Not Rated” means the provider has not enrolled in Ohio's voluntary Step Up To Quality (SUTQ) program — it does not indicate a safety concern, a licensing problem, or substandard care.

Every provider listed in New Middletown already complies with Ohio's mandatory baseline licensing requirements: background checks for all staff, health and safety inspections, required staff-to-child ratios, and annual continuing education.

When evaluating a “Not Rated” provider, review their inspection history on Ohio's Child Care Search, visit in person, and ask about staff qualifications and curriculum.

Source: Ohio Administrative Code 5101:2-17-01 (PDF)

How do I find infant care in New Middletown, Ohio?

Infant care (children under 12 months) is the hardest age group to place — demand consistently outpaces supply. In New Middletown, starting your search several months early is strongly recommended.

When you contact a provider, ask specifically:

  • Do you have openings in the infant room for a child under 12 months?
  • What is your infant-to-caregiver ratio? (Ohio licensing requires a maximum of 1:5 for licensed centers)
  • How do you ensure safe sleep? (Babies on their backs, firm surface, no loose bedding)
  • Are feeding and nap schedules based on each baby's individual needs? (On-demand is best practice)
  • Is there a waitlist? How far in advance should I apply?

Source: Ohio Revised Code 5104.033 | Child Care Aware of America — Short Notice Checklist

What should I ask when I visit or call a daycare in New Middletown?

Before committing to a provider in New Middletown, cover these questions by phone or in person:

Logistics first

  • Do you have space for my child starting on [date]?
  • What are your rates and fees? Do you accept Ohio's PFCC subsidy?
  • What are your hours, holiday closures, and inclement weather policies?

Licensing and safety

  • Is your license current? When was your most recent inspection — were any concerns found?
  • Do all adults complete background checks before spending time with children?
  • Are providers certified in CPR and First Aid?

Quality and daily life

  • What would a typical day look like for my child?
  • How do you handle guidance and discipline at my child's age?
  • What is your screen time policy?

See the full checklist on our FAQ page →

What if I can't find openings in New Middletown?

Ohio Parent Hub does not collect real-time seat availability — openings must be confirmed directly with each provider. If you're not finding what you need in New Middletown:

  1. Browse the county — View all providers in the surrounding county to find programs in nearby communities
  2. Call, don't email — A direct call is faster and signals genuine interest to providers with informal waitlists
  3. Ask about waitlists — Many high-quality centers maintain them; getting on one early is often the best long-term strategy, especially for infants
  4. Ask about PFCC — Providers accepting Ohio's subsidy are marked on listings and can broaden your affordable options significantly

More questions? Visit our full FAQ page.